notessamuele onelia

The Vibecession Born from Two Weeks of Comments

The Story

In June 2022, Kyla coined the term “vibecession” — a portmanteau of “vibes” and “recession” — in her Substack newsletter to describe Americans’ view of an economy whose hard data looked acceptable but felt terrible (Source 3).

The term didn’t appear in one sitting. It was the residue of weeks of getting yelled at in the comments.

“Vibecession was sort of a couple of weeks in the making where, like, we were having these pretty good prints on metrics, like the labor market was doing OK, industrial production was doing OK, everything was OK. But people were feeling really, really bad. So there’s sort of that divergence between how people are feeling and ‘what they should be feeling.’ So the vibecession is this idea that, like, there’s a vibe decline even though the data is OK” (Source 1).

The trigger was a TikTok she made arguing the U.S. was not in a recession. “I had been publishing TikToks because GDP came in negative. And so everyone was like, oh, we’re in a recession. And they made this TikTok being like, we’re not in a recession. Like, we’re not. That’s not the definition of a recession. And I was getting yelled at and people were like, but we need a recession. And I was like, what the heck is going on?” (Source 2).

She wrote a follow-up essay called “Do We Need a Recession?”, got more feedback in the same direction, and the connection clicked: “the economic data is okay, but people are feeling terrible like that. We’re not in a recession or in a bad session” (Source 2).

A lot of the synthesis happened on her bike. “If you’re familiar with my Vibe Session piece, like that was essentially crafted on my bike. Like I was — I biked to and from the gym and I was just — I think about things because all you really do is like pedal and, you know, make sure you don’t get hit by a car. But there’s so much like fluidity to that movement that the way I think about it is like you get your gears going in your brain as you’re pumping” (Source 2).

The framing made it into her book as the “vibe economy” — the idea that popular feelings shape consumer sentiment, which then influences economic outcomes (Source 4). Her own bio now positions vibecession as her signature contribution: “Her debut book and New York Times bestseller, In This Economy? How Money and Markets Really Work, is where she coined the term ‘vibecession’ to describe the disconnect between strong economic data and negative sentiment” (Source 5).

Lesson for Creators

The most-cited idea Kyla has produced was not a thesis she sat down to write. It was a label she gave to something her audience had been yelling at her about for weeks. She had the credentials and the reading depth to validate the feeling against data, and that’s what turned a comment-section frustration into a term that ended up in Bloomberg and the New York Times. For creators: when the same disagreement keeps showing up in your replies, the comments aren’t noise — they’re the prompt. The term that names the thing your audience can’t articulate is often worth more than the essay you were planning to write.

Backlinks

External sources