notessamuele onelia

9,200 Subscribers from One-Way Substack Recommendations

The Story

Tom’s biggest single growth lever for Marketing Ideas is Substack Recommendations — but he runs them differently than most (Sources 1, 2).

Most creators cold-DM each other proposing swaps. Tom doesn’t ask first. “I recommend other Substack writers and promote them (without speaking to them beforehand). I don’t message them or expect anything in return.” (Source 2).

The mechanic exploits a Substack-specific feature: “Substack shows you exactly how many subscribers you’ve generated for others. I use these stats as an excuse to reach out ONLY after I’ve sent them enough subscribers.” (Source 2).

The concrete example: “My recommendations generated over 2,000 subscribers for one writer who didn’t know me. I sent her a LinkedIn message mentioning this, and she immediately recommended my newsletter in return - adding 500+ subscribers to my list in just 5 minutes of work.” (Source 2).

Total subscribers Tom attributes to recommendations: 9,200 (Source 2).

He also offered another version: full guest posts for established newsletters. “Instead of cold-DMing other writers asking for swaps, he offered value first—writing full guest posts for more established newsletters. Not just shoutouts, full articles. Some of his best content, published on someone else’s list.” (Source 1).

After those guest posts performed, “the other writers took notice. Some started recommending him automatically because they saw traffic coming from Tom’s direction… Others did it as part of a mutual exchange, building long-term partnerships instead of one-off swaps.” (Source 1).

Tom’s framing of why recommendations beat social posts: “With Substack recommendations, it’s always alive. I always get new subscribers from those recommendations. It’s a fantastic growth lever.” (Source 1). Unlike social posts, recommendations don’t decay in 48 hours (Source 1).

The HubSpot version emphasizes the relational effect: “I stayed in touch with the authors. Not to squeeze more promotion out of them, but because I genuinely liked their work. When you approach creators as peers rather than as distribution channels, the relationships last.” (Source 3).

Lesson for Creators

Asking for a swap is a transaction. Sending value and waiting until you have receipts is leverage. The trick depends on a platform feature most creators ignore — Substack publishes the actual subscriber attribution numbers, so “I sent you 2,000 subscribers, would you reciprocate?” is a verifiable claim, not a pitch. The pattern generalizes beyond Substack: when you can prove you’ve already created value for someone, the conversation stops being a sales call and becomes a no-brainer. The other half: recommendations compound where social posts decay. A good recommendation pays for years.

Backlinks

External sources