notessamuele onelia

First Question Is Monetization, Not Subscribers

The Story

“The first question you should ask is not how I get the subscribers. It’s how am I going to monetize when I do have them” (Source 1).

In the podcast: “It’s the first question you should ask is not how I get the subscribers. It’s like, how am I gonna monetize when I do have them? And for most people it should be” — choose ads plus a digital product or service first (Source 2).

Nathan’s prescribed validation budget for an opportunist starting from scratch: “I would set a three to six month timeline where, all right, I’m gonna whatever, spend $15,000, that’s my budget for this newsletter initiative. And I’m gonna try to, as quickly as possible, get a couple sponsors and sell some kind of product or service. The people who do that I think are the ones who do quite well” (Source 2).

He frames the cost in time vs. dollars: “You’ll pay for your subscribers one way or the other. You’ll pay with them with your time. You’ll pay with them with your dollars” (Source 2).

The kill criterion is explicit: “The bad thing is sitting in an idea that’s not never going to work, seeing it for a year or two years” (Source 3). “If the answer’s no, that’s okay. It just means you now have, you could go choose another idea and you haven’t wasted too much of the most viable thing, which is your time. The worst mistake you can do is spend two years on an idea that you should have spent six months on” (Source 2).

The validation target at small scale: by 1,000-1,500 subscribers, “1 to 5 people who would pay you $500 to $1000 a month on your list of 1,000 people. That’s how you start to validate an idea before you’ve tried to pay to get to 10,000, 20,000, 30,000 subscribers” (Source 3).

“Getting to 1500 subscribers does not automatically translate into revenue. Getting the first consulting client or getting the first ad sponsors what translates into revenue” (Source 2).

Lesson for Creators

Subscriber count is a vanity metric until a monetization model is attached to it. Before writing your first issue, write down how the newsletter makes money at 1,000, 5,000, and 50,000 subscribers — and what counts as failure. Nathan’s $15K-and-six-months frame is honest math: it’s small enough to walk away from, big enough to actually test, and short enough that pivoting out costs months not years. Most newsletters die from the founder being too patient with an idea that should have been killed at month four.

Backlinks

External sources