notessamuele onelia

Why Paid Newsletters Are Really, Really Hard

The Story

“I think paid newsletters are really hard. Really, really hard” (Source 1).

Nathan named only two scenarios where paid subscription newsletters work well at scale (Source 1):

  1. A giant hyperfan audience — “this would be like if Rowan wanted to, Rowan, who runs the Rundown, he has 600,000, 700,000 followers. He interviews Mark Zuckerberg once a year, like it gets invited, all this AI shit in SF all the time. He could start a paid newsletter because of his scale and because he’s so well known” (Source 2).
  2. You break news, or your analysis is genuinely first-of-its-kind — “the journalist version of that is like Oliver Darcy at CNN… he gets the scoops. So if you’re first right, you have to be first or you have to be best” (Source 2).

For smaller-scale paid newsletters ($100-200K/year), Nathan said you need to fit one of four buckets (Source 1, Source 2):

  • Life transformation (lose weight, etc.)
  • Investing (Market Beat does $40M/year, “probably five of that is through their subscription”)
  • Jobs (helping people get better at their work)
  • Niche hobbies (“there’s this guy, he gets into like Lego investing and teaches you all about how to invest in Legos and he makes like $150,000 a year”)

The economics he flagged for paid: “You acquire a subscriber for about as much as you make on that subscriber in the first year. And so where you start to actually make money is like year two, year three. That’s a long game to play” (Source 2).

When asked about scaling paid via paid ads: “Most of the people who scale paid subscriptions scale it organically” (Source 2). Lenny Rachitsky and Ben Thompson (Stratechery) both came up as examples of audience-driven, organic-grown subscription wins (Source 2).

Lesson for Creators

The romance of the paid newsletter is that you skip ads and get a clean recurring-revenue business. The reality Nathan describes is that the unit economics resemble enterprise SaaS — you spend year one acquiring at break-even and only make money in years two and three, so churn quietly destroys the model unless you’re either famous, first to news, or in one of four high-pain niches. For most operators, ad-supported newsletters with a high-LTV product behind them (the media mullet) outperform paid newsletters of similar audience size, with shorter payback and less existential dependence on retention. Pick paid only if you’re confident you fit a bucket; otherwise, the maths punish you for years.

Backlinks

External sources